About the Author

Holley Gerth is a Wall Street Journal bestselling author, counselor, and life coach. Her newest release is The Powerful Purpose of Introverts: Why the World Needs You to Be You. She's also wife to Mark, Mom to Lovelle, and Nana to Eula and Clem.

Related Resources & Gifts
Find more at DaySpring.com
Related
Resources
& Gifts
Find more at
DaySpring.com
Recent Posts

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Holley,
    I have been on the receiving end of well-meaning advice and plenty of “you should’s”. There’s even been times, when plodding down a very difficult road or panting up an excruciating hill, people have said things like, “just be thankful your situation’s not worse, like ___________ (fill in the blank).” Cliches and even quoting scripture to someone may be the last thing they need….maybe they need, grace, a listening ear, and a shoulder to lean on. I have learned that one of my greatest accomplishments is keeping my mouth shut . Sometimes the less said the better. A well timed hug, an encouraging word, a helpful act, and plenty of prayer, and just being present are often the best acts of grace. Awesome analogy….and message.
    Blessings,
    Bev xx

    • Even more difficult are the ones who are subtly or overtly waiting to see if I have done what they suggested or made improvements in my life. There is always the fear of, or reality of, their giving up on me if I haven’t done enough or if the situation has been resolved. Many times it is not that easy, and I often want to retreat from everyone rather than show that what I tried didn’t work or I didn’t do what was suggested.

  2. I’m absorbing this truth about gratuitous advice in my role as a mother-in-law.
    It turns out there is more than one way to keep a house, feed a husband, care for a baby, and even to be a church woman! It’s amazing all that God can teach a woman whose mouth is closed and whose eyes are open!

  3. Love this post… Love the word picture…. Such a perfectly poignant reminder… .this is something I need to remember and apply every day!
    Grace is the way Christ touched the world… Grace is the way we can show our world Christ… Xoxo
    Grace is also the word the Lord gave me for this year.. It’s also my middle name.. Lol..

  4. When I had cancer, when I discovered our teen sneaking out, when we had church leadership problems, there was always more advice flying round than we needed, wanted, or could take in. As a pastor’s wife I’ve sat with lots of people going through tough things and I’m gradually learning to hold the advice and hold their hand instead, to say “I get it. That’s so tough. I can share what worked for me and what didn’t if you like, but I’m here.”
    Having had the craziest things said to me when I was sick, I really believe other people’s pain makes people uncomfortable and in that discomfort they want to fix it, make it go away, and fill the awkwardness of the moment. Advice is a great filler.
    Thanks for sharing Holley, a beautiful picture and encouragement to cheer people on not push them on.

    • Love this especially! I’ve found that sharing stories are a lot better than giving advice. One reason we need different generations connecting with one another! Especially the good ones! Looking for the good in this world needs to become the daily thing to do!!

  5. As a divorcée then single mom then widow (from cancer) then remarried and a cancer survivor myself all before the age of 49 – believe me…. I have heard a lot of ‘well, you should have’s….’ sadly, most of it has come from my church acquaintances. BUT GOD! I love your response. There most certainly will be hard times and beautiful times – that’s all a part of it! That is exactly what my experiences have led me to share with others. Compassion without judgement. I’m so thankful my Lord and Savior shares his grace, understanding and forgiveness with me everyday! If we are to be his hands and feet – shouldn’t we all try to do the same?! There are people hurting everywhere- it doesn’t take much to share a smile and/or a word of encouragement. It might just be the thing that draws them closer to Jesus and help get them through their day. Thank you for sharing your story!

  6. I’m on my way to visit my daughter for a week this morning. This couldn’t have come at a better time. She’s recently divorced and going through a lot of changes and keeping herself way too busy and I was going to make some suggestions…but, now I’m not. I’m thinking of ways to be more helpful. Thank you Holley, and all the ladies that replied to you. I have certainly learned a lot…and I’m, 82. Who says an old dog can’t learn new tricks. This has also touched me in other ways too. Keeping my mouth shut instead of giving advice, what an amazing option. Blessings to you and all your readers.

    • Elena:

      Have a beautiful viSIT with your daughter. What “timely advice as you received it”. I have gone through some treacherously painful things and the one thing God has me do as my family was fracturing was “love on my parents” – love and honour my parents. He gave “abundantly beyond what I could hope for or imagine “ – navigating our hearts to one another in the deepest sorrow of my life. My mom became my sounding board confidante that she never was before- her listening ear was soothing balm to my heart – even though the miles separated us. God’s Majestic recipe for me became Majestic Splendour in experiencing my mom in a way I never have.

      God gives JOY in sorrow and sends it too. You are His loving and livign postcard of love to your daughter. You are your daughter’s JOY in the sorrow. Just “loving as He loves will be enough for her” but if you could write her out all the “proud mom moments” and affirm her on a page or in a card, I am certain that her heart will soar with gratitude at the memory of the moments you shared.

      I hope that God gives you both
      lavish JOY and His Peace that surpasses in your visit together. Don’t forget to take lots of photographs and may laughter and gentleness be your companions.

      Be blessed. You are a blessing. A daughter has only one mother and you are a glorious one.

      Sincerely, Janine

  7. Holley, as usual, you make me see the other side. My brother always said that there are three sides, yours, mine, and then there’s the truth. We can always see our side. We can sometimes see the other side. But we usually have a hard time seeing the truth – the real, honest and hard truth. It’s so much easier to tell someone else how or why to do something. Much, much harder to be the one struggling, therefore, grace is always the most important thing we can give each other. Thanks for the reminder of how we are to treat each other. Bless you

  8. When we moved to the country years ago, I remember looking along the road and enjoying grass and trees instead of concrete. It looked beautiful, perfect. Some days after moving I decided to exercise by walking that road. But when I got that close I could see the trash woven into the grass– fast food sacks, aluminum cans, plastic wrappers… Once I got close enough to see what it really was, it was not perfect as it had looked from afar. I realized that those friends or celebrities, or neighbors that I looked at longingly thinking they had the perfect life I was missing– if I got close enough I would see that they, too, had imperfection and struggles, and heart aches like me. Maybe not the same but a version of mine.

  9. Holley, your blogs are always timely and grace filled, but somehow, as a former codependent, I needed to read this today. Codependent people try to fix others, so why not make comments or give advice. We’re only trying to support them in their anguish, aren’t we? We need to look more deeply inside ourselves to judge our motives, as I have had to do lately. Yes, it usually involves keeping our mouth shut, while the other person, with dependence upon God, works out his or her own problem. Thank you for the kind reminder.

  10. Holley, as a former codependent, I needed to read this today.
    Codependents try to fix others. Well, isn’t that what “bearing one another’s burdens” is all about? I now have the tools to judge my motives and keep my mouth shut.
    We can trust our Loving Father to be the same Loving Father who is going to provide the answers for another’s problem. We listen, we pray, and we encourage our friend or loved one by telling them God loves them and cares for them and He will guide them through the situation. Some times, while they speak and we listen, God is actually showing them the way forward.
    Blessings on you for your faithfulness to write Truth.

  11. Holley, this is beautiful. Reading this was a breath of fresh air. I’ve been on both sides – needing to ask forgiveness for my insensitivity and feeling impaled by someone else’s. May we all grow in receiving and extending grace!

  12. Thankyou for this devo Holly.
    I am a “fixer”at heart. We currently have a mentally ill adult living with us. It is very trying. We are learning to empathize and listen more, but my “fixer” inclination still gets in the way. I hear God telling me to step back and show love. Stepping back is hard.

  13. After living through infertility & a really tough adoption process twice & receiving so much unsolicited advice & shoulds & God won’t give you more than you can handle bologna ive come to the conclusion that nothing’s better than a plate of chocolate chip cookies & a more that reads “I’m praying for you”

  14. Perhaps advice-givers are doing their best to express love. They see our troubling circumstances and want to help us fix them. / Lord, help me be patient these folks, and just thank them for their input. And let such moments remind me to keep advice to myself unless it’s asked for! / Thank you, Holley, for addressing a common situation. Whether we’re in the position to give advice or receive it, may we seek the grace of Jesus to be wise and discerning.

  15. Thank you Holley for this post. Too often I have been on the giving advice side. When others don’t take my advice, I’m offended.

    Who do I think I am. I really try to lead them to Scripture but more of me is in there than more of God.

    What if I gave more grace than advice. Hmmmm, I believe God will be glorified. I was just talking with a friend about grace. I think God is trying to tell me something. Thank you again.
    Linda

  16. This post is spot on! To often people think they have the answers to our problems. While our situation may look similar to theirs, there could be subtle differences. Everyone doesn’t handle things the same way. I have a friend who was going through tough aging parent issues. Same ones I had with my dad. I just simply told her I understood what she was going through & praying for her. People don’t need or want clique answers to their problems. They want you to be a listening ear & understanding/praying friend. Women, especially, want to fix everything & everyone. Sometimes there is no fixing the problem. Send encouragement now & then. Check on the progress. Keep thy mouth shut otherwise. The best you can do is pray for them & let God handle it.

    Blessings 🙂

  17. My sweet grandmother always told me that God gave us 2 ears and one mouth for a reason…listen more than you talk (or give ‘advice’). But I still get this wrong. Thank you for your great reminder that only God knows it all. We just need to show grace and love.

  18. Holley, so grateful that you shared this story the way you did, the imagery brought me into walking with you. I believe this is well known, but not well practiced. I’ve realized in my ‘rumblings’ that I had an uncomfortable challenge with silence. You see, listening just for listening is an art that I’m practising, yet very often while I’m listening, a million ‘offers to advise’ keep rolling through my mind. Thank you for (in)couraging us to encourage with the grace of Jesus. That is swwwweeettt!

    Rhonda McLeod

  19. Thanks Holley, I am going through a difficult time right now….in my work life, personal life and I really needed this today. I love the way God uses you!

  20. I have just joined your site and am already a fan. Thank you so much for your caring, insightful observations about this Christian walk we undertake. Certainly having experienced a situation before can make us more empathetic , but I think just honest caring about each other can also give us the compassion we need to walk along side our fellow men and women. As the adage says – what would Jesus do?

  21. Love the imagery and the story! I’m wondering how we give grace when we’re on the receiving end of advice – the end that says
    “you’re not ____ enough; you need to change to be acceptable.” My common response is to get defensive, or to withdraw. But how can I be okay enough in my own mess, not necessarily intending to stay in the mess, but okay with where I’m at, in order to reach to those who send potshot advice. Because I’m sure underneath all those words there is a real hurting person who doesn’t have all the answers. Should I ignore/move on in order to protect myself? Wait til they reach a point in their lives when they need someone to come alongside? (Of course by then, there may be no relationship between us!) And make sure I walk in forgiveness so that I don’t end up being the person who is internally saying, ” I told you it wasn’t so easy!”